.
“-self” words can go after verbs or nouns to express a variety of subtle meanings
THE FORMS AND USES OF “-self” WORDS
Words ending in -self – technically known as “reflexive pronouns” – are usually said to have three main uses: as a verb’s object meaning the same as the subject; to add emphasis to a preceding noun or equivalent; and after by to mean “without help”. Most mainstream grammar descriptions deal with these uses, though not always comprehensively.
My purpose here is threefold: to highlight some aspects of reflexive pronouns that I have not found described elsewhere, to assist understanding of the more complicated points by describing them in my own particular way, and to show how -self words are just as important in professional writing as in the less formal communication from which mainstream grammars mostly take their examples.
.
THE OBJECT USE OF “-self” WORDS
An example of this use is:
(a) The parasite usually attaches itself to its victim.
It is clear that itself here, the object of attaches, means the same as the subject parasite. There are a number of interesting observations that can be made about the grammar and meaning of object -self words.
1. Observations about Grammar
The variety of -self words in the table above reflects the fact that as an object they must “agree” with the subject. For example, a plural subject needs themselves as object, a singular female one needs herself, and one sometimes needs oneself (see 204. Grammatical Agreement).
Most verbs that can have a -self object are also usable with an ordinary object without a change of meaning. For example, ATTACH, the verb in (a), could have an object noun like suckers instead of itself. There are, however, a number of verb types that are not like this. For example, CONTENT always needs a -self object followed by with (see 123. Prepositional Verbs Containing a Noun), and BEHAVE needs either -self or no object at all. For a full survey, see 268. Types of “-self” Object.
Object -self words must be distinguished from complements, which also refer back to the subject of their verb (see 220. Features of Complements). I think the reason why -self words are usually objects rather than complements is that they mostly follow a standard object-taking verb (defined in 8. Object-Dropping Errors) rather than a complement-taking one. However, they can also follow complement-taking verbs, such as BE or SEEM, thereby becoming complements:
(b) After the medication the patient was again herself.
This is a rather idiomatic use of -self words not often mentioned in mainstream grammars. It just means “normal”.
Another feature of -self word objects is that they cannot be passive-voice paraphrases as often as they can in some other European languages. For example, the verb DEVELOP could not have a -self word object in the following:
(c) When the reagent was added, a bluish colour… .
Possibilities here are developed or was developed (depending on meaning: see 201. Words with Complicated Grammar 1, #1), but not *developed itself (which would emphasise unusual effort).
On the other hand, revealed itself is possible in (c) (see 242. Words with Unexpected Grammar 3, #b). The reason seems to be the kind of verb that REVEAL arbitrarily is. Whereas DEVELOP is usable in the active form without an object noun (see 4. Verbs that Don’t Have to be Passive), REVEAL is not.
This does not mean, however, that all verbs like REVEAL can have a -self object instead of being passive. SEND, for example, in the letter was sent could not become sent itself. Perhaps the reason is that English -self constructions have a strong suggestion of independent initiative, and associating this with letter movement seems more ridiculous than associating it with revelation.
Yet an active verb expressing the idea of sending after the subject letters is not impossible in English. The way to achieve it is with the active form of a different verb, one possibility being went (see 27. How to Avoid Passive Verbs).
Mainstream grammar descriptions tend to illustrate verbs like DEVELOP with a similar (but not completely the same) kind of verb from everyday English – such as BATHE, DRESS, RELAX, SHAVE, SIT and WASH (though not CLEAN, which needs a -self word). Professional writing has numerous other verbs like DEVELOP, such as IMPROVE, INCREASE, MOVE, OPEN, PREPARE and STOP.
A further infrequently-made grammatical point about -self words is that they can be indirect objects as well as direct ones:
(d) Teachers must allow themselves time to cover material thoroughly.
Once again, themselves corresponds to the subject teachers. The direct object here is enough time. We know that themselves is an indirect object because it can change places with the object, with for placed before it (see 126. Verbs with an Indirect Object).
Finally, the use of -self words after imperative verbs is worth mentioning. A famous example is Know Yourself, a translation of words on an important temple in Ancient Greece. The -self word is always yourself or yourselves, proving that the unmentioned subject of imperative verbs must be you. For more about such verbs, see 128. Imperative Verbs in Formal Writing.
.
2. Observations about Meaning
(I) CONTRAST WITH “each other”
A contrast that is often made is between plural -self words in the object position and each other/one another. Here is a sentence with one of the latter:
(e) In the market place, firms must compete against one another.
This implies competition among three or more firms (if the competition was between only two, each other would be preferred). What is not possible here is themselves, since that would mean firm A competed with firm A, firm B with firm B, and so on – an illogicality. However, English could also say in (d) …compete among themselves.
The -selves/each other contrast is more typically illustrated in English coursebooks by sentences allowing either one, depending on the meaning, like this:
(f) Large apes often groom (1) themselves (2) each other.
The first meaning here is that each ape grooms itself, the second that each ape both grooms and is groomed by another ape.
.
(II) SPECIAL MEANINGS WITH PARTICULAR VERBS
Some verbs use an object -self word differently from the way shown in (a) above. Occasionally there is an idiomatic meaning:
(g) In the task, learners help themselves to a card.
Here help lacks its normal “give assistance” meaning: it means learners take a card independently instead of receiving it from someone else. Other combinations whose meaning is similarly not obvious include enjoy themselves (= “have a good time”), behave themselves (= “avoid bad behaviour”) and express themselves (= “communicate their thoughts”). For more examples, see 268. Types of “-self” Object. For more on ENJOY, see 8. Object-Dropping Errors and 10. Words with Unexpected Grammar 1, #b.
Another exceptional usage is with verbs like DEVELOP and WASH, which I said above normally disallow a -self word object. They can actually be used with one to suggest something extra. In the following, wash means “with new independence”:
(h) Small children quickly learn to wash themselves.
This suggests the washing was previously done by other people.
Another common meaning after verbs that normally disallow a -self word is “with determined effort”. Stopped oneself falling implies taking successful action to stop (unlike stopped falling); and improve oneself means not just getting better, but working very hard to do so. Other verbs usable like this include CHANGE, DEVELOP, MOVE, PREPARE and TIRE. A different meaning again exists with TRAIN: training is preparation for sporting or professional activity, whereas training oneself relates to habits.
.
“-self” WORDS IN OTHER POSITIONS
1. After a Noun
The other main use of -self words according to most grammar descriptions is to give “emphasis” to a particular noun or noun-equivalent. One way is like this::
(i) Students themselves should * choose * what to study *.
The -self word usually follows the noun it “emphasizes” (here students). It can always go directly after and, if the noun is a sentence subject, it can also go in later positions, marked * in (i).
A word I prefer instead of “emphasis” is “contrast”, since that is the precise type of emphasis that -self words mostly show. In (i), students is being contrasted with other people involved in study choice, like parents and/or tutors. The idea of contrast results from the independence idea in -self words – the suggestion of separation from someone or something else. Even non-living things can be thought of as independent, for example by being automatic, and hence can be contrasted with a -self word. In the following, the application contrasts with human computer users:
(j) The application will download updates itself.
The contrast expressed by a noun + -self word can also be with a previously-mentioned noun. Sometimes there are contrasting verbs too:
(k) Parents FEAR for their children on busy roads. The children themselves COPE admirably.
A -self word after the repeated noun is preferred in Standard English to for before it (For the children, they… above – see 125. Stress and Emphasis).
Contrasts like (k) resemble those with but or on the other hand (see 20. Problem Connectors, #3). Indeed, one of these expressions could be added above – with or without a -self word. However, there is not always such equivalence: the noun emphasized by a-self word must also be mentioned in the first part of the contrast – children above. With no previous mention, no -self word can be used:
(l) Parents fear busy roads. Children, on the other hand, cope admirably.
In other -self word contrasts, there are contrasting noun ideas but no contrasting verb ones – the verb ideas are identical:
(m) Most people dislike insects. I myself try to avoid them.
The only additional link words possible here are similarity-showing ones like similarly or also. This noun-contrasting use of -self words is also possible in single sentences:
(n) Members of a category may (also) be categories themselves.
A third sort of contrast made by a noun + -self word is, like the first, with one or more implied rather than mentioned ideas.
(o) Pele himself would not have scored that.
(p) Freezing temperatures occur in the Sahara itself.
In (o), the contrast is with other footballers, in (p) other deserts. In addition, the underlined nouns are extremes: Pele was the greatest goal-scorer ever; the Sahara is the hottest desert. As a result the -self word means “even” and we understand that no footballer would have scored that, and all deserts have freezing temperatures.
.
2. After “by”
At first sight, placing a -self word after by just seems an alternative to the independence-expressing use, since by can easily be added to (i) and (j) above. However, I believe that by does make a subtle difference, introducing the idea of solitariness or isolation alongside that of independence.